In July 2013 Darragh
McManus in his Radio Column in the Irish Independent[1] wrote, when it was
announced that Louise McSharry would temporarily replace Ryan Tubridy on 2 FM,
‘It’s
a big deal because Louise McSharry as you will have gathered from the name, is female.
And 2FM is almost entirely a female free zone. Out of the roughly 20 shows in a
normal week three are hosted by females (one co-hosting with a man). None are
anywhere near primetime.’
He added,
‘The fact that taxpayers fund 2FM – and half are women- seems to make it worse’.
6am Doireann Garrihy
9am Jennifer Zamperelli
12 Noon Tracy
Clifford
3pm Jenny
Greene
6pm Game
on Presented by Marie Crowe (with Ruby Walsh & Donnacha O’Callaghan)
7pm Tara
Stewart
10pm Dan
Hegarty
News Jan O’Connell
But how far has equality come
and now surpassed itself on the national airwaves. By 2014, a Women on the Air
conference claimed only 25% of voices on Irish airwaves were female. Jenny
Greene at the time said,
‘a
woman should only be allowed on the air if she is good enough’.
Fellow broadcaster Alison Curtis who works as
the national commercial station Today FM said,
‘I
don’t think you should put somebody on based on their gender, we need to divide
the talent equally but put the best on the air’.[2]
In 2017, the journal.ie
in an article titled ‘'You won't hear a woman's voice, and it's not
acceptable': What are Irish radio stations doing about gender balance?
They reported,
‘Fierce
discussion has been taking place about gender balance in Irish radio, after it
emerged this month that two of the country’s most high-profile stations, Today
FM and Newstalk (part of the Communicorp stable), do not have any women on air
during peak listening times of 7am – 7pm.’
In 2018, The National
Women’s Council of Ireland (NWCI) asked the Broadcasting Authority of Ireland
(BAI) to monitor the Irish airwaves for gender balance on a yearly basis but
the emphasis seemed to only focus on gender balance as it affected women not
male broadcasters.
As of March 2021, from
6am to Midnight, only 11% of on air voices as male, a different gender
imbalance. It may absolutely be the case that only the best should be heard on
air, those most popular with listeners. This
has to be balanced with the JNLR figures in November 2020 which saw 2FM lose
listeners and Newstalk becoming the second most listened to station Nationwide[3].
Much has been made of gender equality in the workplace over the past decade and major strides have been made in numerous male dominated industries. There has been an improved balance with the Irish radio industry but just as the campaign to gain greater acceptance of female recognition and opportunities, the same must now be applied to the gender imbalance against the males in the industry. Gender disparity in favour of female presenters is not gender equality. The gender equality that RTE DG Dee Forbes said she would address[4] when she was appointed in April 2016 has yet to find a balance.